Top Ohio Republicans face down intraparty critics

By DAN SEWELL and JULIE CARR SMYTH Associated Press Published:

COLUMBUS -- Conservative restlessness within their own party poses challenges to three Republican stars in the battleground state of Ohio, where House Speaker John Boehner, Sen. Rob Portman and Gov. John Kasich all have riled up the right.

Kasich upset some by pushing for certain tax increases and embracing Medicaid expansion under President Barack Obama's health care overhaul; Boehner is clashing with conservative groups over the federal budget; and Portman faces backlash from social conservatives over his about-face in favor of gay marriage.

Whether the GOP trio can hold Republicans together has sweeping political implications, given Ohio's role as a swing state and the three men's own national profiles. Kasich and Portman have been floated as presidential-ticket contenders, while Boehner seeks to hang on to one of Washington's most powerful jobs.

Some party dissidents feel betrayed, seeing an orchestrated effort to court support among the roughly 20 percent of unaffiliated voters in Ohio's middle. Kasich could face a primary challenge in 2014 and lose some conservatives to a Libertarian candidate in November.

People are lining up to oppose Boehner in the district he has held more than two decades, while there's talk of recruiting a primary challenger for Portman in 2016.

"The Republican Party needs to know what it stands for," said Tom Zawistowski, a leader in the Ohio tea party movement. "We're not going to let them slide."

Republican Secretary of State Jon Husted said Boehner, Portman and Kasich face a classic political conflict: whether to follow, or lead, public opinion.

"These guys have been pretty successful in their own right; they're pretty smart politically. They're trying to skate, as Wayne Gretzky says, to where the puck's going to be, not necessarily where the puck is," Husted said. "That path is not always clear."

Ohio consultant Curt Steiner places Portman in the leader category. The Cincinnati native stunned conservative backers in March when he announced his support for same-sex marriage, after his son, Will, came out as gay.

"I think history will show that he was ahead of the curve," said Steiner, who But some conservatives are distrustful now.

"Rob Portman's going to pay a price. He was wrong," said Zawistowski, of Portage County in northeast Ohio.

Kasich's critics suspect he has one eye on 2014 and another on 2016. He has drawn favorable national attention -- including publicly from Obama -- for his push to make Medicaid available to more low-income Ohioans, and for some innovative tax and spending proposals. A big re-election victory in November would almost certainly put him in play for his party's national ticket.

Talk of GOP dissidence doesn't much faze Kasich.

"I don't think anything about it," Kasich told reporters recently. "I'm not interested in all the political ... you know, if I'm interested in anything about politics, I'll read Politico."

Any GOP challengers to the Ohio trio face an uphill battle; perhaps the steepest is in the 8th House District that Boehner, of West Chester, has carried by large margins since his first win in 1990.

"It's going to be one of those David and Goliath fights," said Ann Becker, who leads the Cincinnati tea party, an umbrella for southwest Ohio groups.

Want to leave your comments?

Sign in or Register to comment.

  • I don't understand how this story constitutes front page news. The Tea Party's unfavorability ratings have doubled over the past couple of years and will continue to decline after forcing the government shutdown. For this reason alone, I suspect Husted is summing up the situation correctly with his Gretzky analogy. 

    Every time I read a quote from Tom Zawistowski, I am reminded of how much of a tin ear he has for political realities outside of his tiny, tiny bubble. Even if most Republicans do not identify themselves with the Tea Party, there are areas of strong agreement between these groups. One would think he could use this to his advantage. However, Zawistowski is in a position in which his political group has been slowly and steadily losing support and he still demands that politicians meet his uncompromising expectations lock step. It's a delusional perspective, really. Moreover, his characterization of Rob Portman's turnaround regarding homosexuality as "wrong" comes across as callous. Portman's son came out as gay. Whether one has moral objections to homosexuality or not, Portman's change of perspective is at least understandable and deserves respect.

    Whatever the case, Zawistowski must own stock in the Record Courier because every time he has a fit, everyone has to read about it. 

    By all means, please proceed Mr. Zawistowski. Perhaps we'll get some democrats elected as a consequence. 

  • Conservative extremism may actually help the Democrats win some of these races by splitting the vote amongst the Republicans .  Thank you Tea Party.